Experiments and Falsifiability
How to Test Planck Core Theory
1. Scientific Standards
A scientific theory must make predictions that can, in principle, be proven false. This document specifies:
- Precise predictions of ITT Planck Core theory
- Experimental methods to test them
- Falsification criteria that would disprove the theory
2. Gravitational Wave Tests
2.1 The Prediction
ITT predicts: Ringdown waveforms from black hole mergers should show deviations from GR in the late stages, including:
- Modified damping profile (flattening)
- Possible echo structures
- Strain amplitude capping
2.2 Experimental Setup
Instruments: LIGO, Virgo, KAGRA (current); Einstein Telescope, Cosmic Explorer (future)
Method:
- Detect black hole merger events
- Extract ringdown portion of waveform
- Compare to GR template predictions
- Search for systematic deviations
2.3 Specific Tests
Test A: Damping Modification
GR Prediction: Ringdown amplitude decays exponentially.
ITT Prediction: Modified decay with flattening at late times.
Observable: Deviation from exponential in final 10-50 cycles.
Statistical Significance Required: 3-sigma deviation from GR template.
Test B: Echo Search
ITT Prediction: Periodic structures in post-merger signal.
Method: Cross-correlate post-ringdown signal with ringdown template.
Current Status: Claimed 2-3 sigma echo signals exist in LIGO data (controversial).
2.4 Falsification Criteria
ITT would be falsified if:
- All ringdowns match GR templates exactly (no late-stage modification)
- Strain exceeds predicted Planck Core limit
- Echo searches consistently yield null results with high sensitivity
3. Hawking Radiation Tests
3.1 The Prediction
GR Prediction: Black holes evaporate completely, ending in gamma-ray burst.
ITT Prediction: Radiation ceases at Planck-lock. No final burst.
3.2 Experimental Setup
Instruments: Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope, SWIFT, future gamma-ray telescopes
Target: Primordial black holes (PBHs) with M less than 10^15 g
3.3 Falsification Criteria
ITT would be falsified if:
- Clear detection of PBH evaporation burst with GR-predicted spectrum
- Thermal spectrum continues to diverging temperatures
- Complete evaporation observed (no remnant)
4. Black Hole Shadow Tests
4.1 The Prediction
ITT Prediction: Planck Cores produce:
- Sharper inner shadow edge
- No inner glow from Hawking radiation
- Modified photon ring structure
4.2 Experimental Setup
Instruments: Event Horizon Telescope (EHT), future space-based VLBI
Targets: Sgr A*, M87*, other nearby supermassive black holes
4.3 Falsification Criteria
ITT would be falsified if:
- Shadow structure matches GR predictions exactly
- Detected thermal emission from central region consistent with Hawking temperature
- No edge sharpening observed at high resolution
5. Summary of Falsification Criteria
Strong Falsifiers
The theory would be strongly falsified if:
| Test | Falsifying Observation |
|---|---|
| GW Ringdown | All ringdowns match GR perfectly |
| GW Echoes | No echoes in high-sensitivity search |
| Hawking Radiation | Observed PBH evaporation burst |
| Shadow | No inner edge modification |
| Remnants | No evidence for Planck Core population |
Confirmations
The theory would be supported if:
- Ringdown deviations at greater than 3-sigma
- Echo structures confirmed
- Absence of PBH evaporation bursts
- Sharp shadow edges detected
- Planck Core dark matter component identified
6. Experimental Roadmap
| Timeline | Experiment | Test |
|---|---|---|
| 2025-2030 | LIGO O5 | Ringdown deviations |
| 2025-2030 | EHT | Shadow structure |
| 2025-2030 | Fermi | PBH burst absence |
| 2030-2035 | Einstein Telescope | High-precision ringdown |
| 2030-2035 | LISA | SMBH mergers |
| 2035+ | Next-gen EHT | Sub-horizon resolution |
| 2035+ | Advanced gamma-ray | Comprehensive PBH search |
7. Conclusion
ITT Planck Core theory makes specific, testable predictions that differ from General Relativity. The theory is falsifiable:
- If GW observations match GR exactly
- If PBH evaporation is observed
- If shadow structure shows no modification
- If no Planck Core remnants exist
Current and near-future experiments can decisively test these predictions.